Did Huppenthal Flip-Flop on Common Core Yet Again?

Matthew Hendley

State Superintendent of Public Education John Huppenthal has made mixed statements about his stance on Common Core.

Today, the incumbent may have flip-flopped still again.

See also:
-Garcia Accuses Huppenthal of Flip-Flopping on Common Core

Huppenthal was initially a strong proponent of the Common Core standards, called the College and Career Ready Standards here in Arizona. He once referred to opponents of the standards as "barbarians at the gate."

But in a radio interview late last month, Huppenthal said he was opposed to the "new definition" of Common Core and that he would seek a review of the standards to "keep all the good stuff" and to cut what he referred to as the "crap." And in an August 5 debate with his opponent for the Republican seat, Huppenthal said, "I have never supported the Common Core standards."

But in a video message released this morning, Huppenthal again changes his tune.

"I have always supported rigorous standards that prepare our students for success in college, career, and life," he says. He cites Common Core components he supports, including basic reading and math standards.

He then goes on to make clear just what constitutes the "crap" portion of the standards, saying he will oppose elements touching on such debated topics as, oh, history and science. "I will always oppose any standard that presents an unbalanced debate on scientific topics like climate change," he says, "and I will always oppose any standard aimed at denigrating our Founding Fathers and the U.S. Constitution."

But Huppenthal seems open to continued discussion of the merits of Common Core.

"I intend to partner with the next governor and the education community to fully review the standards in a series of open public forums to ensure that we are implementing standards that are best for Arizona students," he says in the video.

Diane Douglas, Huppenthal's Republican opponent in the August 26 primary, has built her campaign platform around stopping Common Core in the state. Her website, in answer to the question of why she is running, says, "Quite simply, to stop the Common Core Standards in Arizona."

In the Democratic primary, David Garcia, an education professor at ASU, will run against Sharon Thomas, a teacher. Garcia supports Common Core as part of the school improvement equation, but wants it to be used in the scheme of a larger school accountability structure that looks at more than just test scores. "Where I differ from all of the other candidates in this race is my belief that we need to look beyond standardized tests to measure student academic achievement," he says.

Thomas supports Common Core, claiming to be "the only candidate who has written curriculum aligned to Common Core and taught under the CC standards."

The general election for State Superintendent of Public Education will be held on November 4.

Got a tip? Send it to: Ashley Cusick.

Follow Valley Fever on Twitter at @ValleyFeverPHX.

Follow Ashley Cusick on Twitter at @AshleyBCusick.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
Heather Feaga
Heather Feaga

I don't think he's trustworthy because he's an internet troll.


<B>just as Leonard answered I am taken by surprise that a single mom can make $7907 in a few weeks on the internet . check my source ............. is.gd/SqfQ6y<B>

WhoKnows topcommenter

Huppy should never hold public office again, but his opponent is even more nuts, and given the old farts in sun city, the opponent could win the general based on votes of people that used a chalkboard to write answers on their tests!

If Hoopy makes it to the general, no  one sane would vote for him...


Hopefully, the voters will "cut out the crap" in November.

But, this is Arizona so probably not. 

They'll just do a "fecal transplant."

valleynative topcommenter

I'm not a supporter, but "flip-flop" is grossly over-used by the media and certainly doesn't seem to apply here.

If he said yesterday that he likes fruit, but today he admits that he doesn't like plums, that doesn't make him a flip-flopper. If he said he doesn't like the current contents of Common Core, but does like standards, that's not flip-flopping, either.

eric.nelson745 topcommenter

Jeez, this Huppenthal dude lies like a rug. First he denied that he talked trash in blog posts made under a pseudonym. Now he keeps flip-flopping concerning common core. It's a clear attempt to keep his core conservatives and assorted religious nut bags from bailing on him. We're all looking for an honest man, and he isn't one.

Now Trending

Phoenix Concert Tickets

From the Vault