Immigrant Detainees Go on Hunger-Strike Over Conditions at Pinal County Jail

Categories: News
pinal-county-jail-cells.jpg
Gregory Pratt
Cells inside the Pinal County Jail.


Immigrant detainees being held at the Pinal County Jail were on a hunger strike over conditions at the jail, according to the human-rights group Puente.

Long before conditions at facilities for child migrants came to the forefront, complaints were lodged against the Pinal County Jail, which is used as a federal immigrant-detention facility under a contract with Immigration and Customs Enforcement.

See also:
-Immigrants Who Fight Deportation Are Packed Into Federal Gulags for Months or Years

Puente released a letter signed by 150 detainees at the jail, documenting a series of complaints about conditions at the jail.

The allegations are remarkably similar to those laid out in a New Times cover story about the Pinal County Jail, which was published nearly three years ago.

The detainees complain about not being able to go outside, not having the proper conditions to fight their immigration cases, very high costs for phone use, and no contact visits with family members.

It looks like some things don't change. Here are some excerpts from that 2011 story:
The Pinal County Jail is one of five facilities in Arizona used by the federal government to hold immigrants in long-term detention. The jail is notorious among immigration attorneys and human-rights advocates, who consider it the state's worst immigrant-holding facility. . .

The Pinal County Jail was built in April 1996 to hold 472 prisoners. In 2006, the building was expanded to include 1,032 new beds.

To help fund the incarceration complex, Pinal County signed a contract with the federal government to hold more than 600 immigrants at any given time. The jail is the second-largest detention center for immigrants in the state. Only the Eloy center is larger, with 1,500 detainees.

Pinal County makes $59 a day per detainee, meaning its contract is worth $36,000 a night -- $13 million a year. . .

Immigrant detainees at the Pinal County Jail are isolated from outside contact, unlike detainees at the Florence Detention Center, Florence Correctional, the Central Arizona Detention Center, and the Eloy Detention Center.

Pinal County is the only federal contractor in the immigrant-detention business in Arizona that does not allow its prisoners to go outdoors.

The Pinal County Jail also is the only facility that does not allow prisoners to see family in person. . .

Pinal County contracts with a private company for its phones, and a 15-minute phone call can cost $20 -- money that few detainees have. (The situation is a little better at Florence Detention, where calls cost 17 cents a minute.) The result is that many county detainees cannot contact their relatives. . . ICE is quick to emphasize that it requires contractors to sign an agreement to uphold federal detention standards and that humane treatment of immigrants is paramount among these standards.

Mandates include warm meals and access to outdoor recreation. As mentioned, the Pinal County Jail refuses to provide the latter to the immigrants it holds, even as it allows criminal inmates outdoor privileges.

This despite a 2009 internal ICE report, "Immigration Detention Overview and Recommendations," acknowledging that there are major differences between corrections and detention -- mainly that corrections are "punitive" and detention is "civil."

The ICE report emphasizes that the philosophy of "care, custody, control" is inappropriate when dealing with immigrant detainees.

ICE acknowledges that it does not train its contractors to follow federal detention standards, which was obvious when New Times interviewed Pinal County Chief Deputy Kimbell, who is in charge of the jail.

Asked whether he sees a difference between "criminal inmates" and "detainees," Kimbell answers, "Corrections, detention -- it's all the same thing" . . .

Detainees are still kept indoors and denied access to their families at the Pinal County Jail, which, [an ACLU attorney] says, is the "perfect example" of how detention facilities punish immigrants for deciding to fight their civil cases.
Also from that story is a short profile of how the jail conditions affected one woman and her family:
Leticia is a Guatemalan who spent 21 months in ICE custody, 12 of them at the Pinal County Jail. She was the single mother of two minors, 17 and 8, when she was detained. Both are U.S. citizens.

In January 2009, after living for 20 years in Phoenix, she was taken into ICE custody. Leticia's case is, like most immigrants' cases, full of complications.

She applied for legal status in 1996 and was granted it in 1997. But with the passage of a 1996 immigration law, the rules for earning legal status changed, and a judge retroactively applied the new law to her case, denying her plea to remain in the United States.

The attorney representing Leticia did not specifically challenge the retroactive ruling in his appeal, and the immigration Board of Appeals authorized her deportation in 2002. Her attorney appealed that order and, in 2004, the Ninth Circuit federal appeals court affirmed that she could be deported.

ICE did not take her into custody until January 2009.

The next month, a different attorney filed a habeas corpus petition on her behalf in the Ninth Circuit, arguing that the immigration court got its ruling wrong, her previous lawyer had been incompetent, and deporting her would be a grave injustice for her family, creating orphans the state would have to care for.

While the court considered her petition, Leticia was detained by the federal government and denied contact with her family.

After a couple of weeks in the Pinal County Jail, Leticia asked an ICE agent how long she might expect to be imprisoned.

When Leticia finished explaining the details of her case, the agent looked at her and said, "Cases like yours take seven to 10 years."

Leticia was horrified and considered signing a deportation order to get out of jail. But her teenage daughter, Leslie, wanted to remain in America, so she decided to continue fighting her case.

For more than a year, Leticia was not allowed to see her children, except on a small, primitive computer monitor attached to a telephone receiver. The situation was the same for the children, who viewed their mother on a corresponding monitor in the jail's visiting area.

No-contact visits are a jail rule for not only criminal inmates but for immigrant detainees. There is no face-to-face contact (not even through plexiglass), much less any touching.

It took more than a year after Leticia was taken by ICE for her to hug one of her children, and it happened as a fluke. Her 8-year-old son began crying for his mother during her court hearing, and a guard had the heart to allow them a short visit.

The separation adversely affected the boy. Depressed, he started failing in school.

During a phone call from jail before the hearing, Leticia had asked him what was wrong. "He started to cry and cry," she remembers. "'He said, 'Mommy, it's never going to be the same without you.' It was so terrible."

Visits from family and friends occur in a cramped room containing two rows of dingy monitors, with a camera perched atop each screen and a phone beside it. The detainee never sees his or her relative except in a grainy transmission that looks like security-camera footage.

ICE officials claim to be sensitive to detainees' need for contact visits.

They tell lawyers and activists that detainees at the Pinal County Jail are allowed in-person visits with family members -- if they file a special request.

But in statements to New Times, ICE representatives tell different stories about the issue of contact visits.

Vincent Picard, agency spokesman in Arizona, says ICE "regularly" takes detainees from the Pinal County Jail to Florence Detention for contact visits, a claim contradicted by ICE field officer Marty Zelenka, who supervises federal detention in the county jail.

Zelenka says he never has denied a request for a contact visit but has received "very few."

Immigrant advocates at the ACLU and detainees say otherwise, insisting that contact visits are denied routinely at the jail.

"Almost all detainees to whom we spoke either indicated they were denied requests for contact visits or did not know they could even request such a visit," states the Arizona ACLU in a just-released report titled "In Their Own Words: Enduring Abuse in Arizona Immigration Detention."

As for the extremely limited visitation system at the jail, Leticia's daughter, Leslie, tells New Times that on several 65-mile trips from Phoenix to the jail to see her mother, she was turned away because prisoners had been put on lockdown or there was a problem with the jail's computers. Sometimes she was told to come back the next week.
Again, the detainees' letter, which is embedded at the bottom of this post, describes many of the same circumstances.

According to Puente, about 70 of the men went on a hunger strike, but ended it a couple of days ago after getting a commitment from ICE to review their demands.

Got a tip? Send it to: Matthew Hendley.

Follow Valley Fever on Twitter at @ValleyFeverPHX.
Follow Matthew Hendley at @MatthewHendley.


My Voice Nation Help
14 comments
JoeArpaioFan
JoeArpaioFan

"Almost all detainees to whom we spoke either indicated they were denied requests for contact visits or did not know they could even request such a visit," states the Arizona ACLU in a just-released report titled "In Their Own Words: Enduring Abuse in Arizona Immigration Detention."

JUST REMEMBER THAT DETENTION IS NOT LIKE A BURGER KING. THEY CANNOT HAVE IT THEIR WAY.

JoeArpaioFan
JoeArpaioFan

Leticia is a Guatemalan who spent 21 months in ICE custody, 12 of them at the Pinal County Jail. She was the single mother of two minors, 17 and 8, when she was detained. Both are U.S. citizens.

THE ANCHOR BABY LOOPHOLE MUST BE CLOSED. SHE SHOULD HAVE THOUGHT ABOUT THE CONSEQUENCES OF KIDS BEFORE SHE DECIDED TO HAVE THEM HERE.

In January 2009, after living for 20 years in Phoenix, she was taken into ICE custody. Leticia's case is, like most immigrants' cases, full of complications.

NO COMPLICATIONS. IT'S REALLY QUITE SIMPLE.... SHE'S ILLEGAL SO DEPORT HER... PERIOD!

She applied for legal status in 1996 and was granted it in 1997. But with the passage of a 1996 immigration law, the rules for earning legal status changed, and a judge retroactively applied the new law to her case, denying her plea to remain in the United States.

SAME SHOULD APPLY TO EACH AND EVERY ILLEGAL ALIEN... DEPORT!

JoeArpaioFan
JoeArpaioFan

The Pinal County Jail also is the only facility that does not allow prisoners to see family in person. . .

CAN AMERICANS HELD IN COUNTY JAILS ABLE TO VISIT THEIR FAMILIES IN PERSON? NO!  IN MARICOPA COUNTY VISITS ARE CONDUCTED VIA VIDEO MONITORS.  WHY THEN SHOULD IMMIGRANT DETAINEES BE TREATED ANY BETTER THAN CITIZEN DETAINEES?

Pinal County contracts with a private company for its phones, and a 15-minute phone call can cost $20 -- money that few detainees have. (The situation is a little better at Florence Detention, where calls cost 17 cents a minute.) The result is that many county detainees cannot contact their relatives. . . ICE is quick to emphasize that it requires contractors to sign an agreement to uphold federal detention standards and that humane treatment of immigrants is paramount among these standards.

BUT WHAT ABOUT AMERICAN CITIZEN PRISONERS IN ARIZONA JAILS AND PRISONS WHO CAN AFFORD A $20 PHONE CALL?  DON'T GO TO JAIL THEN AND YOU CAN ENJOY THE CONVENIENCE OF YOUR CELL PHONE ON THE STREET.

Mandates include warm meals and access to outdoor recreation. As mentioned, the Pinal County Jail refuses to provide the latter to the immigrants it holds, even as it allows criminal inmates outdoor privileges.

AGAIN, IF YOU DON'T LIKE THE RULES DON'T GET ARRESTED. JUST REMEMBER THAN JAIL IS NOT 24 HOUR FITNESS CENTER.

This despite a 2009 internal ICE report, "Immigration Detention Overview and Recommendations," acknowledging that there are major differences between corrections and detention -- mainly that corrections are "punitive" and detention is "civil."

NO, JAIL IS JAIL. IT IS A CRIME TO ILLEGALLY ENTER THIS COUNTRY SO THEREFORE EEVRY ILLEGAL ALIEN BROKE FEDERAL LAW. STOP TRYING TO MAKE EXCUSES.

The ICE report emphasizes that the philosophy of "care, custody, control" is inappropriate when dealing with immigrant detainees.

REALLY? WHY SHOULD IMMIGRANT DETAINEES BE TREATED LIKE KINGS AND QUEENS? IF YOU DON'T LIKE THE WAY YOU ARE TREATED THEN COME HERE LEGALLY!

Asked whether he sees a difference between "criminal inmates" and "detainees," Kimbell answers, "Corrections, detention -- it's all the same thing" . . .

YES, CRIMINAL INMATES AND DETAINEES ARE THE SAME.


Detainees are still kept indoors and denied access to their families at the Pinal County Jail, which, [an ACLU attorney] says, is the "perfect example" of how detention facilities punish immigrants for deciding to fight their civil cases.

YEAH RIGHT... WRONG!  IMMIGRANT DETAINEES ARE LAWBREAKERS AND THEY SHALL NOT BE TREATED ANY DIFFERENTLY.  THE ACLU'S LOGIC MAKES ABSOLUTELY NO SENSE.  AGAIN, A DETAINEE IS A CRIMINAL.

john043012
john043012 topcommenter

I think this entire situation will be taken care of after the 2014 midterm elections. the empowerment the Obama administration has given to the illegal immigrants will be squashed. Last week an unknown beat Canter on the sole issue of dealing with our southern border and dealing with the P.O.S. jerkoffs (like the above mentioned) in our jails.

armandocdll81
armandocdll81

We all need to go on a diet once in a while - let them starve. If they want to eat they can go back home. 

Gary Rorrer
Gary Rorrer

Good...we save tax dollars..give them bread and water..good nuff!

jasonrdawleyy
jasonrdawleyy

ʟɪᴋᴇ Sʜᴀɴɴᴏɴ ʀᴇsᴘᴏɴᴅᴇᴅ I ᴀᴍ ᴅᴀᴢᴢʟᴇᴅ ᴛʜᴀᴛ sᴏᴍᴇ ᴏɴᴇ ᴀʙʟᴇ ᴛᴏ ɢᴇᴛ ᴘᴀɪᴅ $7564 ɪɴ ᴀ ғᴇᴡ ᴡᴇᴇᴋs ᴏɴ ᴛʜᴇ ɪɴᴛᴇʀɴᴇᴛ . Fɪɴᴅ Oᴜᴛ Mᴏʀᴇ 



>>>>>>>>>>>  WWW.Jℴbs75.ℂOM

fishingblues
fishingblues topcommenter

I have never figured the logic behind a hunger strike.


"Let's torture ourselves.  That'll show 'em."  

Matthew Clemens
Matthew Clemens

LOL You come from a country filled with crap, murder and drug cartels and you are going to go on a hunger strike over an air conditioned facility, a warm bed and an actual place to crap instead of squatting on a cactus? GTFO of my country and stay where you belong!!!

Derek Mason
Derek Mason

let them starve. Maybe they should have thought about the consequences before crossing the border illegally and they should be charged for every part of their confinement and extradition back to their country of origin. Let them starve and die and do the US a favor and rid this country of illegals

JoeArpaioFan
JoeArpaioFan

Screw them, let them starve then. They can stomp their feet and throw a tizzy fit until they are blue in the face but they have nothing coming except a free ride back to Mexico which is what should happen. Deport!

danzigsdaddy
danzigsdaddy topcommenter

Criminals, inmates and detainees are not the same twit. Detainees are people being held while they see if charges can be made, inmates (not all) are usually people held on charges pending conviction (some are convicted) and criminal is a vague wording. If they had said convicted criminal it would have meant those who were charged, had their case heard and lost and or were sentenced or convicted

A detainee could very well be an innocent person

Guest
Guest

Lemme guess. You're pushing 40 and still living with mom and dad in their cramped little vinyl-sided house in a dying farming hamlet in some obscure corner of the Midwest. Your family is secretly ashamed of you, and no woman will touch you. You'd love to escape, but you can't cut it on your own. Rather than facing your own inferiority like a man, you spend your free time (when you're not masturbating, watching Trailer Park Boys, or working on your truck) ranting about non-white people (of whom only an unlucky two or three live in your entire town), including especially the President, who you claim to believe is a foreign-born Muslim terrorist. We get it; every loser needs his scapegoats. But these people didn't make you a failure. You were born that way. And nobody cares what you have to say.

Now Trending

Phoenix Concert Tickets

From the Vault

 

Loading...