Half-Baked ABC 15 Report Misses the Complete Story on Florence Cops

Categories: News analysis

Former Florence police detectives Walt Hunter and Jarris Varnrobinson.
An ABC 15 reporter told viewers a story earlier this month about two former Florence detectives who'd botched cases so badly that the Pinal County Attorney's Office couldn't prosecute them.

Only no one has been able to cite what the cases were about.

See Also: Florence Exposed: New Times' Three-Part Investigative Series on the Florence Police Department

"The County Attorney's Office says it had to drop five other cases, blaming mistakes made by [Walt] Hunter and [Jarris] Varnrobinson," reporter Navideh Forghani said on camera.

Though it may sound as if the County Attorney's Office is disseminating current information, it's not.

The allegations of poorly investigated cases against the two cops were made years ago, in late 2010 or early 2011, by former Deputy County Attorney Susan Crawford.

Forghani didn't mention this in her report.

Further, Jim Knupp, spokesman for the County Attorney's Office, said his office isn't aware of the five "other" cases.

"We did not confirm or deny — just to be perfectly frank — that there were five cases because we're not aware [of them]," Knupp said, regarding ABC 15's story.

The PCAO is aware of only one case — an alleged rape — that officers are accused of mishandling, which Forghani also mentioned on-air.

Her report also doesn't inform viewers that ex-prosecutor Crawford testified under oath that she wasn't sure why she didn't provide to Florence Police Chief Dan Hughes the file of improperly investigated cases that she claimed to have.

"I don't know why I didn't get [him] the file," Crawford said in a hearing over the two detectives' dismissals from the Florence Police Department. "I know I had it."

Forghani tells New Times she won't comment on her story on the record. The video of the report no longer was available on the station's website.

An attorney representing the officers in a pending lawsuit against Florence says she plans to ask ABC 15 to retract the story.

On camera, Hunter and Varnrobinson primarily are criticized over how they handled a rape case involving a then-17-year-old who accused her stepfather of having sex with her.

Forghani pulled soundbites from the recorded interview between the alleged victim and the officers. The investigators were criticized as having been too harsh in the interview. They suggested that they didn't believe the teenager by asking questions that were "biased," then-prosecutor Crawford said.

As it turns out, the officers' doubts may have been well-placed.

An eight-day trial of the case ended March 13 with a not-guilty verdict after jurors deliberated less than an hour.

"They found the accuser's allegations were not credible," says attorney Michael Freeman, who represented the stepfather and spoke to members of the jury after the trial. "Her story changed dramatically during the trial compared to what she'd told detectives."

Even when shown transcripts from her recorded interview with Hunter and Varnrobinson while on the stand, Freeman said, she denied ever making the statements.

The police report in the case states that in late 2012, when Hunter walked into the interview room — where the teen already was sitting with another cop — he heard her ask the officer what would happen to her if they found out she was lying.

Hunter also documented in the police report that the girl's biological father had pulled him aside before the interview and told him to be wary because his daughter had made false allegations against others in the past.

It's with this background that the officers began their interview.

Forghani also reported that Hunter and Varnrobinson should have taken the alleged rape victim to a nearby Family Advocacy Center, where forensic interviewers question vulnerable victims on behalf of police. She said they instead interviewed the girl in a "room like this one," as the camera pans over a police meeting room.

Hunter and Varnrobinson said they intended to take the young woman to the advocacy center, but there wasn't a forensic interviewer available at the time.

Hunter said he informed his sergeant of this and that the sergeant ordered them to interview the teen at the police station.

When all this happened, it was Susan Crawford who expressed her concerns to Alden "Butch" Gates, a lead investigator for the center.

In September 2011, these issues were hashed out at a meeting that included several representatives from the County Attorney's Office, the police department, the two officers, and the advocacy center.

The group reached a consensus that the officers had insufficient training in interviewing juvenile victims of sex crimes.

Gates, a nearly 30-year police veteran with specialized training in sex crimes, told officials that when he started, he also found himself criticized for his inexperience. But, he told them, he had learned through his mistakes and additional training.

After Hunter and Varnrobinson received further training, the matter was closed.

That is, until Chief Hughes, who officially joined the Florence department in November 2012, revived the allegations, assigned nefarious intentions to the officers' mistakes, and fired them in December 2012.

At their appeals of their dismissals in September 2013, the hearing examiner shot down Hughes' attempt to dredge up the rape investigation, saying he couldn't reopen an old disciplinary matter that had been settled.

"It's shameless how [those] who fired our clients are so desperate to discredit them that they're willing to repeat allegations that already have been disproved at a hearing," said Lynne Bernabei, a Washington, D.C.-based attorney representing Hunter and Varnrobinson in their pending lawsuit.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

This is disturbing on many levels.

First, it is disturbing how the Florence Town Manager and the  Florence Town Council are standing by and supporting the Florence Chief of Police in his relentless efforts to persecute the two former Florence detectives Varnrobinson and Hunter when it is more than obvious they have done absolutely nothing unlawful or unethical. 

Second, for a reporter such as Navideh Forghani who works for a statewide news agency such as Channel 15 to go on the air and disparage the two detectives without all the facts of the case is nothing short of disgraceful. I will certainly never watch that news program again. Varnrobinson and Hunter were heavily criticized by Ms Forghani and  her "expert witness" Robert Bell (who also didn't have all the facts prior to speaking) for thinking the "victim" was being untruthful and as it turned out in court...the two detectives were obviously correct. Ms. Forghani should be forced to go back on air and give a profound apology to both detectives she so heavily disparaged.

And lastly, is is shocking how quickly Pinal County Attorney Lando Volyes has jumped in lockstep with the "Pinal County Good Ol Boys" and assisted them in attempting to destroy the careers of the detectives.  All allegations made by Dan Hughes and the Town of Florence against them has now been shown to be totally untrue in a hearing. Further,  Arizona POST reviewed their case and found no fault with their actions. These undeniable facts certainly had no effect on Volyes and Company who ignored all information and placed them on the Brady Integrity List when Varnrobinson and Hunter seem to be the only ones in this situation without any integrity issues. It is more that obvious from following this situation that the detectives only "crime" was turning in one of the "Good Ol Boys" for breaking the law.  Sadly, County Attorney Lando Volyes seems to be more than willing to trade politics for principle and seems to think that by assisting Florence in their endeavors against the two, it may gain him some political support at election time. 

The message here from the Town of Florence and the Pinal County Attorney's Office is that if you see one of the "Good Ol Boys such as Lieutenant Tryon or one of the other "Good Ol Boys" breaking the law, it is best that you look away and keep your mouth closed or you will will receive the same punishment. The next time the public wonders why more honest cops don't step forward with information about unlawful behavior being committed by the "Good Ol Boy" cops; now you know!!


She reads a script. It's quite obvious none of these "reporters" are journalists.

Kelly J Kelly
Kelly J Kelly

Interesting. I'm a fan of "both sides" of a story. Good job.


You are accusing ABC15 of being half-baked?  This rag has a lot of nerve to accuse others of being half-baked. Look at the crap that is spewed out here.

Piss of ABC15 and they will get sweet revenge. They'll tear you apart.

eric.nelson745 topcommenter

I don't watch Ch. 5 or Ch. 15 because of shit like this.



I went to this link, the video is not there. 

Showing that, you are full of b.s., and the author of this report has her facts down.

Are you related to someone who works at ABC 15? Or do you work there yourself? 


@TheyCallMeMrTibbs @somerville  

"somerville" may even work for or be related to (1) Mayor of Florence, (2) Chief Hughes, (3)  Lieutenant Terry Tryon, or any of the numerous "good old boys" that seem to be hell-bent on running the town of Florence right into the ground. Thank you Phoenix New Times for telling it like it is!

Now Trending

Phoenix Concert Tickets

From the Vault