U.S. District Judge G. Murray Snow Questions Maricopa County Sheriff's Office's Right to Detain People Based on Scant Evidence of Crime

Categories: Bad Cops







snow murray judge 500w.jpg
U.S. District Judge G. Murray Snow

Does the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office have the right to detain you if you seem to be violating one element of a criminal statute?

The office's lawyer, Tim Casey, is arguing with U.S. District Judge G. Murray Snow over that question right now in this morning's hearing in the Melendres vs. MCSO racial-profiling case.

Casey says yes, the deputies can.

Snow is highly critical of the stance. He asks whether MCSO could detain him under a simple premise: "If you'll fix my doorknob, then I'll take you to lunch."





One of the elements to meet a violation of the state's human smuggling
law, which the MCSO uses to bust illegal immigrants and is a key issue
in the Melendres case, is whether the smuggling is a commercial
transaction.



Snow gets Casey to agree that, in his example, the transaction is commercial.



Casey argues that the MCSO could detain him for the doorknob deal, in
theory, but wouldn't because the investigating deputy wouldn't be acting
reasonably.



Snow asks Casey why he shouldn't enjoin the MCSO from detaining people based on that "single element" idea.



Casey struggles to answer, but says he doesn't believe the judge could
do that, because it would prevent the sheriff's office from carrying out
its law enforcement duties.



Snow seems incredulous.

Like this Story?

Sign up for the Weekly Newsletter: Our weekly feature stories, movie reviews, calendar picks and more - minus the newsprint and sent directly to your inbox.

Privacy Policy

Most Popular Stories

Sign up for free stuff, news info & more!

Tools

General

Electronics

Auto

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy