Final Exit Network Murder Case Should Go to Jury Today

An eight-person jury is to start deliberations today in a difficult case involving a suicidal Phoenix woman and a national right-to-die organization.
Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for final exit.jpg
Will the jury be able to unanimously decide this one?


Superior Court Judge Paul McMurdie is presiding at the manslaughter trial of co-defendants Larry Egbert and Frank Langsner, who are charged in the 2007 assisted suicide of 58-year-old Jana Van Voorhis.

The defendants, who are both in their 80s, are members of the Final Exit Network, known as the most radical of the current "right to die" organizations.

Dr. Egbert, a Maryland native, is the group's medical director and "approved" assisting Van Voorhis with the suicide (everything short of actually physically help the woman with the actual act). He didn't know Van Voorhis, nor did he set foot in Arizona until after his grand-jury indictment and arrest.

Scottsdale resident Langsner was a volunteer "junior exit guide," who first advised the mentally troubled woman about how she could kill herself painlessly if she wished--inhaling helium through a hose, with an oxygen-eliminating hood snugly over her head.

The retired college professor was at Van Voorhis' central Phoenix home with another Final Exit volunteer (who earlier pleaded guilty to a lesser charge and testified for the prosecution) in April 2007 when the woman killed herself.

Yesterday, the jury began to hear closing arguments in the unusual case, which has touched on complex legal and ethical issues. (The PBS show Frontline is planning to run a documentary on the case and has videotaped the entire trial.)

Here is a story published a few years ago that provides all the background you might need.

Both defendants are charged with conspiring to commit manslaughter (assisted suicide in this instance), and Langsner also is charged with actually committing the manslaughter. Neither man testified in his own defense, nor did they offer any other testimony on their own behalf.

Deputy county attorney Patrick Johnson told the panel that the Final Exit defendants' intent was clear.

"We're not talking about an ignorant organization," the young prosecutor said. "They're smart people. They know know, and they knew they were breaking the law...They knew full well what they were doing."

Don Samuel, a Georgia attorney serving as one of Egbert's lawyers, argued that "this is not a Gambino crime family, like the Maria or something...[Final Exit] is not a group that encourages, actively participates, or advises anybody to commit suicide."

The veteran attorney obviously knows that the word "advises" may come back to haunt the defendant, and he smartly tried to deal with it head-on.

One of Judge McMurdie's jury instructions says that "to aid" means "to assist in the commission of an act." That assistance can include both "active participation" and "advising the person to commit suicide."

The definition of "advice" is fraught with possible interpretation, as the evidence unquestionably showed that both Langsner and his onetime co-defendant Wye Hale-Rowe were intimately involved with Jana Van Voorhis' demise. 

One point worth noting as the jurors begin to deliberate: For legal reasons, they never learned that Van Voorhis was not seriously physically ill when she committed suicide, but was suffering from long-term mental illness.



Advertisement

My Voice Nation Help
9 comments
Donna Ross
Donna Ross

Don't people "the LAW" have better things to arrest people for???!!!! Whose Life it is it Anyway?  If I chose to die by my own hand back off.  I would like info and would absolutely consider therapy. Figuring how and then my moral value and the my relationship with God and what God advises me to do...is my business.  If I am deemed mentally disabled I cannot deside to live or die?  That's God's decision anyway. Come on...I don't plan to die at anytime soon.  I have no control in the "big picture". But perhaps the big picture includes me to help figure out why people kill for no reason.  Murder in the name of the law...There is much....blah. lol. 

linbb
linbb

Versace is a name with resonance in the fashion industry due to the amazingly style and high quality. Shop the latest Versace boots handpicked by a global community of independent trendsetters and stylists. Offer cheap replica Versace women’s boots and sell at a discount. The Versace boot is on sale now. Take a look at these crazy Versace Cut-Out Platform Boots! You can't stop looking at them! No matter what age, what the weather is outside, it is important that everyone should wears some kind of eye protection. Our shop offers Cheap Sunglasses, a wide range of sunglasses and goggles. You can from soozone.com website choose your favorite cheap Sunglasses. Now what really knocked me out are the cheap sunglasses.Oakley store online news and Oakley store online reviews help you know more detailed information about Oakley store online. Our Oakley Sunglasses online shop is your best choice!Many fashion & top quality replica Oakley sunglasses are cheap sale for men & women online. It is a wiser approach for online purchasing Oakley sunglasses because you are able to clearly compare the appearance and preciseness of the replica. Buy Oakley Sunglasses online with confidence.

Robert Rivas
Robert Rivas

I see your headline writers still haen't figured out what "murder" means.

Truth to Power
Truth to Power

I just noticed this, but isn't "Final Exit" a rather ominous name? Who'd want to attend a "Final Exit" event, unless, of course, it's a metal band concert. Then it would make sense.

linbb
linbb

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$Dear customers, thank you for your support of our company $Here, there's good news to tell you: The company recently $launched a number of new fashion items! ! Fashionable $$$$$and welcome everyone to come buy. If necessary, $$$$$$$welcome to :===== www. soozone.com======== $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

linbb
linbb

Versace is a name with resonance in the fashion industry due to the amazingly style and high quality. Shop the latest Versace boots handpicked by a global community of independent trendsetters and stylists. Offer cheap replica Versace women’s boots and sell at a discount. The Versace boot is on sale now. Take a look at these crazy Versace Cut-Out Platform Boots! You can't stop looking at them! No matter what age, what the weather is outside, it is important that everyone should wears some kind of eye protection. Our shop offers Cheap Sunglasses, a wide range of sunglasses and goggles. You can from soozone.com website choose your favorite cheap Sunglasses. Now what really knocked me out are the cheap sunglasses.Oakley store online news and Oakley store online reviews help you know more detailed information about Oakley store online. Our Oakley Sunglasses online shop is your best choice!Many fashion & top quality replica Oakley sunglasses are cheap sale for men & women online. It is a wiser approach for online purchasing Oakley sunglasses because you are able to clearly compare the appearance and preciseness of the replica. Buy Oakley Sunglasses online with confidence.

Deniseaz
Deniseaz

what about MURDERS by HOSPCE >>>??? or even ATTEMPTED MURDER BY HOSPICE OFTHE VALLEY ????

Now Trending

Phoenix Concert Tickets

From the Vault

 

Loading...