Another "Failed State" Article About Arizona Implies Everything Would be Rosy, Except for Conservatives

failed state boston.JPG

Arizona's conservative, anti-immigrant politics help make it a "failed state," says the Boston Review in a lengthy article published today.

The piece makes plenty of good points, but gets watered down by writer Tom Barry's overly simplistic solution. If Arizona simply raised taxes, elected liberal leaders, embraced the federal government as a gentle father-figure and welcomed undocumented workers with open arms, Barry seems to be saying, we'd be doing great.

It's probably tough to understand Arizona's challenges when you're from a state where the poor stay poor and the rich grow ungodly wealthy.

For instance, Barry writes that:

The surge of illegal immigration over the past two decades has in many ways enriched our economy and communities. But--occurring outside the law and in the absence of a shared national plan of sustainable economic growth--illegal immigration contributed to the erosion of our society's sense of community.

In other words, illegal immigration causes only perceived problems -- not real ones.

Barry depressingly concludes: 


Arizona as we now know it cannot survive, even if there is another housing boom around the corner and government budgets are stabilized. The Arizona model of sprawling, low-density desert cities was built on the myths of limitless water and perpetually cheap gas and construction labor. The entire country faces the onset of climate change and energy scarcity, but no state will confront as squarely as Arizona the consequences of its patterns of unsustainable development. Instead of moving to meet the challenges of the future, Arizona is decimating educational infrastructure; it is already demonstrating its loyalty to old ideologies over long- term planning.

We won't quibble with this or most of Barry's well-thought-out (albeit left-of-center) points. We're just not that pessimistic about our state's future because, well, it's our state. In any case, we're not moving to Boston, where it's too cold and just too East for us.

Thanks to SB1070, everyone seems to want to psycho-analyze Arizona lately. Barry's article isn't all that original: A quick Google search turned up another article along the same vein by TPM Muckracker, this one entitled "Arizona: Failed state, Failed Immigration Policies."

Yesterday, Bloomberg News published a lengthy article that ties the state's stance toward immigration to the economy, mentioning that Hispanics will be the largest ethnic group in Arizona in another generation.

With the country's media intellectuals focused on Arizona's economy and immigration laws, our problems should soon be solved.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

This to inform you of a person living and working in the United States illegally. The names that this person assumes are as follows: Gabriela Sanchez (her niece), Karla P. Durazo (her aunt), Patty Durazo (her sister),Julieta Sanchez (her aunt), Patty Sanchez (her sister/her niece) Rocio Sanchez (her sister), Mayra Viramontes (her cousin), Karen Durazo (her cousin),Kenya Durazo (hercousin), Karina Sanchez (her cousin).All of the names assumed by her can be substantiated through her facebook account which is under the name Gabby Sanchez.Her Employer is: Dr. Larry Stark   3201 W. Peoria Ave # A-100   Phoenix, AZ 85029Her assumed Social Security # is her Aunt's Soc. Sec. # 611-32-7757 (Karla P. Durazo) who actually lives in California.She drives a pathfinder with AZ lic. # AHT4587 Her address is: 2220 W. Mission Ln. #1095 (which is in Larry Starks name /  Phoenix, AZ 85017    co-signed for)  SRP Acct # 919-863-000    (which is in Larry Starks name)Her Phone # 602-628-3116   (which is in Larry Starks name)Family Assistance Administration Case # 00564738 (Gabriela Sanchez)Dental work provided under the name Patty Sanchez. And full medical (BCBS)is paid for by Larry StarkHer sons name is Carlos Flores-Sanchez and he graduated from Cortez High School.She was raised by her Grandmother who was a whore in Mexico. This young woman makes it easier for other illegals to obtain medications includingnarcotics and evade citizenship tests through the Doctors office that she works in.Also supplying them with false identification and documentation. I am very concerned about the illegal activities (Document Fraud, Identity Theft, Conducting crimes in America) that she is involved in. Please address the above issues as soon as possible.

Concerned Citizen 


Even though the writer is from NM, it's ironic that the piece appears in a Boston publication, which exists in a state that is eroding quickly from the government-mandated universal health care debacle and the rest of the nanny state policies it has adopted over the years.


The Boston Review is a nationally published magazine.


Just FYI — Tom Barry lives in New Mexico. Thanks!


Barry is from New Mexico.


Dear customers, thank you for your support of our company.Here, there's good news to tell you: The company recentlylaunched a number of new fashion items! ! Fashionableand welcome everyone to come buy. If necessary,welcome to :===== www. ========T-shirts (Polo ,ed hardy,lacoste) $14New era cap $10

Air jordan(1-24)shoes $30

Handbags(Coach,ed hardy,lv,d&g) $35

Jean(True Religion,ed hardy,coogi) $35


Bikini (Ed hardy,polo) $18

Now Trending

Phoenix Concert Tickets

From the Vault