Canadian Newspaper Retraces How Local Murderer was Spared Death Penalty in Mean, Old Arizona

Categories: News

pilipow paul.jpg
Image: Arizona Department of Corrections

Ten years ago, a team of Canadian defense lawyers and diplomats pressed then-Maricopa County Attorney Richard Romley to spare the life of a man convicted of murdering an elderly Valley woman.

Romley relented, deciding not to seek the death penalty against Paul Pilipow (pictured) and persuading the victim's family to see it his way, says an article in today's Canada's Leader-Post newspaper. The paper is on its second day of a look into the 1999 murder of 68-year-old Eloise Doyle and how the man who killed her escaped a death sentence.

Chances looked slim to save Pilipow, at first:

pilipow cherie.jpg
Image: Arizona Department of Corrections

His wife had turned on him. The victim's family wanted him dead. And in conservative states like Arizona, elected sheriffs and prosecutors are reluctant to back down in death-penalty cases.

Romley wanted Canadian officials to guarantee they wouldn't try to transfer Pilipow home, the article says, but Canada typically refused to make such assurances. So Colin Robertson, Canada's consul-general in Los Angeles from 2000 to 2004, took it upon himself to make the written guarantee. Robertson was later disciplined by his superiors, the article says.

Pilipow ended up getting sentenced to life in prison.

In the Day One article, the SaskLeader-Post article's author, Jason Warick, makes a big deal of how Pilipow and his wife/accomplice Cherie (at left) spent about two years "under the control of the Maricopa County prison system, headed by Joe Arpaio..." although that seems to have nothing to do with the overall story. Maybe Arpaio shows up in Day Three.

What a sob story by this Canuck! Do Canadian readers really care this much about sparing the life of a guy who, according to Warick:

1) Decided to steal an RV and kill its owner.
2) Carried out the plan by going to the home of Doyle with his wife and infant, kidnapping her and taking her motor home.
3) Hit Doyle in the head, then dumped her bound body out of his car and killed her by running over her several times.
4) Set fire to the victim's body in a half-assed attempt to conceal the crime.

Prison records show neither Pilipow nor his wife, who will be released in about 12 years, aren't model inmates.

Thanks to Canada, Arizona taxpayers will be rid of Pilipow later rather than sooner.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

I went to school with Paul and he was always a psycho. He was the kid who would drive a grain truck to school with a shotgun and or 30-30 perched on the gun rack. No joke, unlike Paul Pilipow. I know his family and they are nice people. Do not judge them by their son's horrendous actions.


@Keven  I also went to school with paul. yeah he was a little rough and  did some stupid stuff just like the rest of us  but  he was like a brother to  me. He was always  there for me. I still believe it was that bitch that he was married to that made him get into the frame of mind to do what he did


If he were in Canada, he would be out on parole by now.The victim's family can be thankful that he's there and will never walk free.

Now Trending

Phoenix Concert Tickets

From the Vault