Seether's Holding Onto Strings Better Left to Fray

Categories: Album Review
seether_holding onto strings_sized.jpg
Seether's sixth studio album, Holding Onto Strings Better Left to Fray, comes out today. The good news is, fans of the band will find that this is Seether's best album yet. The bad news is, it's still not good enough to garner the band a whole lot of new fans.

Lyrically, not much has changed. Front man Shaun Morgan is still pissed off, feeling slighted, and raging at those who've wronged him. On "Country Song," the first single from the album, he sings, "Well I can't stand to look at you now." On the lead track, "Fur Cue," he orders someone to get out of his head and adds, "You've made me realize that it's all a lie." On "Here and Now," he laments, "I'll never belong inside your world."

Musically, some of the songs on Holding Onto Strings have a harder edge than Seether's previous hits like "Karma and Effect" and "Fake It." The guitars are grittier, and there are some good metal riffs in some of the tracks ("Fade Out," "Down"). But these tracks are also more melodic than anything else Seether's previously done, and come out sounding more emo hard rock than heavy metal. Cases in point: "No Resolution," a classic verse-chorus-verse formula song that sounds like something Fall Out Boy might have recorded on an off-day, and the power ballad "Here and Now," which sounds as radio-ready as anything Nickelback's done. Speaking of Nickelback, Seether wrapped up a tour with them right before recording this album. So maybe it's no coincidence that a lot of Seether's new songs resemble a lot of old Nickelback songs.

For all Shaun Morgan's lyrical sadness and anger, the best track on Holding Onto Strings Better Left to Fray is "Tonight," an uncharacterically optimistic pop song with a huge chorus backed by a tidal wave of soaring guitars, where Morgan sings, "I'm sick of complaining about a beautiful life."

Well, then Morgan should stop complaining. Because when every angry track on the new album is contrasted with "Tonight," they don't hold up. Instead, the album as a whole comes off as a glimpse into the band's still-unrealized potential. It sounds like they just stuck with what worked -- and it's not working anymore.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

This album is disapointing, i was hoping for some new great Seether tracks, instead its all mediocre radio rock, with some average heavy guitar thrown in. Nothing on this album comes close to Fake It, Like Suicide, FMLYHM, Gasoline, Fine Again or Broken. Niki has it spot on, they do sound like Nickelback, which really doesnt do it for me. I dont see how they think this is their heaviest album yet, let alone their best, its a step backward as far as i am concerned.


For one thing, Karma and Effect is an ALBUM. Fake It is a SONG off of the ALBUM Finding Beauty in Negative Spaces.  I hate pop-loving egotists who shit rainbows and puppies.  People have problems.  And as Shaun puts it, some people love music because "they realize someone fucking GETS it."

Oh, and Tonight is shitty radio ready pop rip off.And Seether is post-grunge band, not pop. 


What a bastard - it is superb. How about you try to write and sing and perform just one song. Yeah, I didn't think so.

Now Trending

Phoenix Concert Tickets

From the Vault